This Article Full Text (PDF) References Alert me when this article is cited Alert me if a correction is posted Citation Map Services Email this article to a friend Similar articles in this journal Alert me to new issues of the journal Add to Saved Citations Download to citation manager Request Permissions Request Reprints Add to My Marked Citations Citing Articles Citing Articles via HighWire Citing Articles via Google Scholar Google Scholar Articles by Geller, L. Search for Related Content Social Bookmarking                   What's this?

The Failure of Self-Actualization Theory

A Critique of Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow

230 Arno Road, Venice, Florida 33595.

This inquiry critically examines the self-actualization theories of Carl Rogers and Abraham Maslow. Neither theory, it is argued, is correct. The fundamental claims of each, especially about the self and the human condition, are shown to be radically mistaken. Rogers's theory is unacceptable insofar as his conception of the touchstone or standard of self-actualization is false, incoherent, and unworkable in practice. Maslow's theory must be rejected because of an inadequate anthropodicy (theory of evil) and ontology. First, Maslow's explanation of one major form of human diminution, what he calls the "metapathologies" of contemporary life, undermines the normative foundations of his theory. Second, the logic of human development upon which the entire edifice of his theory rests is shown to be essentially reductionist and radically mistaken. Because of this commitment to a reductionist logic, Maslow is unable in principle to offer an adequate account of the origin and nature of the self and human needs. Beyond considerations of truth, each theory is exposed has having a strong ideological character insofar as it expresses and supports relationships of dehumanization. Beyond critiquing Rogers and Maslow, I attempt to establish the general presumption that self-actualization theory as such has very little to offer toward understanding and improving the human condition within late-twentieth-century Western society.

CiteULike    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    What's this?

This article has been cited by other articles:

				T. L. Hanks The Ubuntu Paradigm: Psychology's Next Force? Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 2008; 48(1): 116 - 135. [Abstract] [PDF]

				I. Laas Self-Actualization and Society: A New Application for an Old Theory Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 2006; 46(1): 77 - 91. [Abstract] [PDF]

				C. Ginsburg The Somatic Self Revisited Journal of Humanistic Psychology, July 1, 1996; 36(3): 124 - 140. [Abstract]

				R. H. Quinn Confronting Carl Rogers: A Developmental-Interactional Approach to Person-Centered Therapy Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 1993; 33(1): 6 - 23. [Abstract]

				R. L. Schott Abraham Maslow, Humanistic Psychology, and Organization Leadership: A Jungian Perspective Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 1992; 32(1): 106 - 120. [Abstract]

				J. Tobacyk and M. Miller Comment on "Maslow's Study of Self-Actualization" Journal of Humanistic Psychology, October 1, 1991; 31(4): 96 - 98.

				T. P. Brennan and M. M. Piechowski A Developmental Framework for Self-Actualization: Evidence from Case Studies Journal of Humanistic Psychology, July 1, 1991; 31(3): 43 - 64. [Abstract]

				J. G. Ford Inherent Potentialities of Actualization: An Initial Exploration Journal of Humanistic Psychology, July 1, 1991; 31(3): 65 - 88. [Abstract]

				A. Neher Maslow's Theory of Motivation: A Critique Journal of Humanistic Psychology, July 1, 1991; 31(3): 89 - 112. [Abstract]

				J. G. Ford Rogerian Self-Actualization: A Clarification of Meaning Journal of Humanistic Psychology, April 1, 1991; 31(2): 101 - 111. [Abstract]

				W. Mittelman Maslow's Study of Self-Actualization: A Reinterpretation Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 1991; 31(1): 114 - 135. [Abstract]

				K. J. Shapiro Animal Rights Versus Humanism: The Charge of Speciesism Journal of Humanistic Psychology, April 1, 1990; 30(2): 9 - 37. [Abstract]

				M. Daniels The Myth of Self-Actualization Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 1988; 28(1): 7 - 38. [Abstract]

				S. R. Wilson The "Real Self" Controversy: Toward an Integration of Humanistic and Interactionist Theory Journal of Humanistic Psychology, January 1, 1988; 28(1): 39 - 65. [Abstract]

				R. Adams and J. Haaken Anticultural Culture: Lifespring's Ideology and Its Roots in Humanistic Psychology Journal of Humanistic Psychology, October 1, 1987; 27(4): 501 - 517. [Abstract]

				D. Lethbridge A Marxist Theory of Self-Actualization Journal of Humanistic Psychology, April 1, 1986; 26(2): 84 - 103. [Abstract]

				C. Ginsburg Toward a Somatic Understanding of Self: A Reply to Leonard Geller Journal of Humanistic Psychology, April 1, 1984; 24(2): 66 - 92. [Abstract]

				L. Geller Another Look at Self-Actualization Journal of Humanistic Psychology, April 1, 1984; 24(2): 93 - 106. [Abstract]